Yes, the title says it all.
However, before going into the nitty-gritty of our distaste for content marketing, We’ll have to define it first. For this, who better to turn to than the Content Marketing Institute, which says: “Content marketing is a strategic marketing approach focused on creating and distributing valuable, relevant, and consistent content to attract and retain a clearly-defined audience - and ultimately, to drive profitable customer action.”
Now does this sound familiar to you?
Those disciplined and trained in the ways of traditional marketing would be shaking their heads, saying, these are essentially marketing and advertising principles. The definition seems like it's been strung together by picking out various components of integrated marketing elements. In doing so, makes itself sound like the de facto marketing guru in modern day business.
Some people swear by content marketing, while others take it more with a pinch of salt (well, a big pinch for some). For those in the latter camp, the rise in subscribing to and believing in the idea of it obliterates much of the knowledge and experience gained in the line of work.
This is why Googling the words ‘content marketing’ and ‘hate’ brings up countless other articles, much like this one.
The Great Debate
To be clear, content marketing is not a novel concept, if these objectives of advertising and promotion for the past century are anything to go by:
- · Develop concepts aligned with brand positioning
- · Create consistent visuals, texts and slogans aimed at the target consumers
- · Place them in the right media channels that target and convince the right people to part with their money
What has shaken up content marketing as we know it, however, is the advent of the digital age. With the Internet, consumers have not only become smarter, but also a lot more discerning.
Just two decades ago, brands were in full control of their marketing messages. In the absence of free-flowing information, consumers took marketers at their word and brands didn’t suffer backlash from misleading advertising. Today, brands have to be careful of what they say and how they say it to avoid being boycotted. Remember United Airlines, Uber, Pepsi and Breadtalk? And these are just a few of the examples. This new dynamic has put a lot of focus on how marketers craft their messages and their campaigns.
So, it seems like ‘content marketing’ really is just another way of expressing traditional marketing principles in this digital age. To make it more relatable to the current landscape, we shall henceforth definecontent marketing as the dissemination of valuable information in the form of texts, visuals or videos on the online platform.
Creating The Right Content
David Ogilvy, known as the father of advertising, has this to say about the subject: “The more informative your advertising, the more persuasive it will be.”
Now that the Internet has such a low barrier of entry, it seems like anyone can publish or upload just about anything. This has resulted in a major content overdose, most being meaningless and useless. To make matters worse, marketers have been led to believe this mantra: Put out as much content as you can; the more you do, the more likely a customer will land on you.
When the objective of putting out content becomes a mere quantity game, more often than not, the quality of the content would suffer. This would in turn, affect the usefulness of the content as well.
Remember that the power balance between brands and consumers have since tipped in the latter’s favour. Now, they can choose to skip over an ad to get to a YouTube video, or read the first paragraph of a blog post, and hit the ‘x’ button if they don't like anything they’re watching or reading. To prevent getting passed over, marketers have to be really conscientious about the content they produce for the World Wide Web.
There are three rules to remember when planning content:
1. It has to contain useful and accurate information
The sheer amount of available ‘content’ (and as of late, fake news) has made consumers more conscious of what they choose to pay attention to. All they really need is the right information to make an informed choice. When they believe the messages to be true and accurate, there is a higher likelihood that they will buy more from the brand.
Take Dove’s long running Real Beauty campaign for example. Through research, Dove found that only 2% of women globally considered themselves beautiful (Etcoff, Orbach, Scott, & D’Agostino, 2004). The brand used that statistic to create an awareness campaign about beauty standards. Dove also debunked the media’s standard of ‘beauty’ by showing how makeup and digital alterations can make an average woman look like a supermodel. This gave women the confidence to not conform to society’s beauty standard and encouraged them to own their beauty, whatever their shape is. The campaign’s success in sharing real personal stories sparked a trend of redefining beauty standards.
2. It has to be relevant
Perhaps the best way to talk about relevance is to use an example of irrelevance. In 2013, Nesquik created a random day called National Bunny Ears Day. They also created an accompanying hashtag (#nationalbunnyearsday) and an app which added cute bunny ears into pictures. Unfortunately no one cared for a made-up day dedicated to bunny ears, mimicking a mascot they can’t relate to.
The moral of the story: content has to be relevant for consumers to engage - the bunny ears could’ve taken off if Nestle chose run the campaign during Easter instead.
3. It has to be consistent
Consistency is mentioned most because of how the mind gets conditioned. It is how people learn to identify and respond to stimulants in their environment, which through repetition, brings about a change in behaviour. How did we come to know that BMW is about performance driving? The brand used the tagline ‘The Ultimate Driving Machine’ consistently for 40 years, before changing it to ‘Sheer Driving Pleasure’ only a few years ago. In contrast, Chevrolet changed their tagline 18 times since the 1950s, making it difficult to solidify a perception. This results in consumers not being able to relate to the brand, only to the products.
Target Audience and Touch-Points
In order to create information that is valuable, relevant and consistent, marketers have to know who they want to reach out to. Trying to target their message to the masses will not work because it will not mean the same thing to everyone. That said, it is also not enough to identify a segment, because this overly generalises a collective group of people with varying needs and wants. So, crafting content requires a deeper understanding of consumers within each identified segments. It has to be granular.
The team behind P&G’s Swiffer Wet Mop identified its target audience as women who wanted a product with convenience. When this message didn’t work in Italy, the team dug deeper and found out that strength of cleaners is more important to Italians instead. This prompted P&G to rework its messaging, which eventually resulted in huge success of the brand there.
A clear understanding of the target audience also means that marketers can identify the right touch-points for their messages. Aside from increasing the effectiveness of outreach, it also maximises the value of ad spend. If, for example, Facebook isn't highly utilised to search for a B2B service, is there a better alternative to advertised on? A platform strategy is therefore essential to achieving maximum engagement with all the different target audience segments — and this, of course, starts with knowing your consumers.
Do we really hate content marketing?
It’s not that we actually hate content marketing, but rather, we abhor the misguided attention it has received, which can make projects impossible to manage at times.
For content marketing to work, marketers will have to remember the basics of marketing principles: identifying sound strategy and objectives, figuring out the right target audiences, creating relevant content, and deploying the most suited channel strategy.
AKIN uses in-house frameworks to plan our content strategy, and they may be of help to you. Check them out here! (2020: Oops, we are currently updating out content frameworks. Thanks for your patients. Do drop us a note at email@example.com and we will zap it over as soon as they are ready!)
Written by Raine Lim
Updated by Hanson Ng (Nov 2019)